Can an Employer Deny Remote Work as a Disability Accommodation? New Georgia EEOC Settlement Highlights the Risks

Remote work has become a common feature of the modern workplace, but employers continue to face difficult questions about when working from home is legally required as a disability accommodation.

A newly announced settlement involving an Atlanta-based company provides an important reminder: An employer’s preference for in-person work does not necessarily override its obligations under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).

On November 13, 2026, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) announced that Osmose Utilities Services, Inc. agreed to pay $25,000 and implement additional workplace measures to resolve a disability discrimination lawsuit involving an employee who requested remote work after suffering a stroke. See https://www.eeoc.gov/newsroom/osmose-utilities-pay-25000-eeoc-disability-discrimination-lawsuit. 

What Happened?

Osmose Utilities, an Atlanta-based provider of infrastructure support services to utility companies, employed a worker at its Peachtree City, Georgia, office.

According to the EEOC’s lawsuit, the employee suffered a stroke while at work and subsequently lost her peripheral vision. After returning from medical leave, she requested permission to work remotely as an accommodation for her disability.

The EEOC alleged that in-person attendance was not an essential function of her position and that the company had previously permitted her to work remotely.

Nevertheless, the company denied the accommodation request and terminated her employment approximately seven weeks after she returned from stroke-related medical leave.

The EEOC filed suit in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, alleging violations of the ADA.

The parties resolved the lawsuit through a two-year consent decree requiring the company to pay $25,000 to the former employee, provide specialized training to supervisors and human resources personnel, post a workplace notice, and submit periodic reports concerning disability accommodation requests.

The settlement resolves the allegations without establishing a judicial finding that the employer violated the ADA.

When Is Remote Work a Reasonable Accommodation?

The ADA requires covered employers to provide reasonable accommodations to qualified employees with disabilities unless doing so would impose an undue hardship.

An accommodation may include modifying workplace policies, adjusting schedules, providing equipment, or allowing an employee to perform job responsibilities from another location.

However, the ADA does not establish an automatic right to remote work.

The central question is whether the employee can perform the essential functions of the position with the proposed accommodation.

For some jobs, physical presence is indispensable. A warehouse employee responsible for handling inventory, for example, may need to be physically present to perform essential duties.

Other positions may involve responsibilities that can be performed effectively through telephone communications, electronic records, and computer-based systems.

When an employee requests remote work because of a disability, the employer should evaluate the actual requirements of the position rather than rely exclusively on a general return-to-office policy.

Why Previous Remote Work Arrangements Matter

One particularly important allegation in the Osmose lawsuit was that the employer had previously allowed the employee to work remotely.

Prior remote work arrangements can provide relevant evidence about whether physical attendance is genuinely essential.

For example, if an employee successfully performed the same responsibilities remotely for an extended period, that history may undermine an employer’s assertion that the position categorically requires in-person attendance.

Nevertheless, previous remote work does not automatically establish that permanent remote work is reasonable. Employers may identify legitimate operational changes, essential duties, supervision requirements, or other circumstances affecting the feasibility of continued remote work.

The Eleventh Circuit has recognized that regular workplace attendance may be essential for certain positions. See EEOC v. St. Joseph’s Hospital, Inc., 842 F.3d 1333 (11th Cir. 2016), which also addresses reasonable accommodation and reassignment.

The appropriate analysis remains individualized and fact-specific.

The Importance of the Interactive Process

The ADA’s reasonable accommodation framework generally contemplates communication between the employer and employee to identify an effective accommodation.

When an employee requests remote work because of a medical condition, the employer should evaluate the employee’s limitations, essential job functions, and potential accommodations.

If full-time remote work is not feasible, alternatives might include hybrid scheduling, modified hours, assistive technology, or adjustments to nonessential responsibilities.

An employer is not necessarily required to provide the employee’s preferred accommodation if another effective accommodation is available.

But automatically rejecting a request without adequately evaluating the circumstances can create significant litigation exposure.

Five Practical Takeaways

1. Evaluate essential functions, not merely workplace preferences. Employers should distinguish duties that genuinely require physical attendance from those that can be performed remotely.

2. Review prior remote work arrangements. An employee’s history of successfully working remotely may be relevant evidence when evaluating a requested accommodation.

3. Engage in an individualized assessment. Accommodation requests should be evaluated based on the employee’s limitations, actual job responsibilities, and available alternatives.

4. Document accommodation decisions. Employers should maintain records identifying the request, accommodations considered, relevant operational concerns, and reasons for the ultimate decision.

5. Consider alternatives before termination. If the requested arrangement is not reasonable or would impose undue hardship, employers should evaluate other effective accommodations before making an adverse employment decision.

The Bottom Line

The Osmose settlement reinforces an important principle for Georgia employers and employees: Remote work is neither automatically required nor automatically unreasonable under the ADA.

The answer depends on the employee’s disability-related limitations, the essential functions of the position, and whether the requested accommodation would impose an undue hardship.

As employers continue refining return-to-office policies, individualized accommodation assessments remain essential to effective ADA compliance.

Contact Information